Publication Date: November 2026
Research and Editorial Team: Edited by RonNell Andersen Jones & Sonja R. West

Lincoln Agnew

Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University

All rights reserved

“The Future of Press Freedom: Democracy, Law, and the News in Changing Times” is an edited volume of 26 chapters by about thirty US legal and media scholars. It grew out of a collaboration with the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University and a symposium held on World Press Freedom Day 2024. The editors start from the premise that the American press is in a risky moment. The commercial news model has collapsed, local outlets are disappearing, and public trust is falling. Officials increasingly attack journalists, while platforms, algorithms and generative AI reshape how information is produced and how it circulates. The authors argue that legal and conceptual frameworks built for a stable twentieth-century press can no longer fit this environment.

The main conceptual move of the book is to shift the question from who is the press to its function: “Rather than fixating on who is the press, our focus should be on what can be done to ensure a future for the press function” (p. 4). The editors argue that press freedom cannot be protected unless the roles the press plays in a democracy are clearly articulated. These include informing the public, checking power, contributing to public discourse and sustaining a shared public sphere. Once the function is defined, law and policy can be designed to protect whoever performs it, whether a legacy outlet, an independent reporter or a citizen communicator. The book is organized into five parts, which together move from spotting the issue to suggesting proposals:

  • Democracy and the press function: the authors examine why the press matters constitutionally and politically. They discuss its relationship with political conflict, violence and the public sphere, and the responsibilities of citizens in an ecosystem where professional journalism plays a smaller role.
  • Evolving threats: they describe an "evolving mosaic of threats" of pressures beyond government censorship, including economic collapse, declining trust, defamation litigation, doctrines that fit new media poorly, platform power and AI. Public misunderstanding of what the press contributes is itself treated as a threat, which leads to calls for a more benefit-oriented way of talking about journalism.
  • Legal protection: contributors propose reinvigorating the Press Clause, drawing on state constitutions and on the Court's expansive treatment of religion. They also defend and update existing protections, such as “New York Times Co. v. Sullivan”, and call for reform of rules on undercover reporting and access to government information.
  • Identifying performers of the press function: the authors ask how law and government agencies can recognize those doing press work without drawing the line too narrowly or too broadly. They call for a more inclusive press that addresses its past exclusion of marginalized voices. They also argue that broader protections for all speakers, such as limits on law-enforcement overreach, may sometimes serve journalists better than press-specific exceptions.
  • Supporting the press function: the most forward-looking contributions argue that protecting the press is no longer enough. They propose public funding, new institutions and innovation policy, with safeguards against government, and some argue that the Constitution may require state action to preserve the news.

The book spots the issues and in doing so it offers a constructive view, it rejects fatalism and concludes that the future of press freedom depends mainly on three things: clearer thinking about what the press does, doctrinal and legislative reform that follows the press function rather than a fixed idea of the press, and willingness to support journalism positively, not merely shield it from interference.

In conclusion, it is important to note that the book is explicitly focused on the United States, and its proposals are tied to the American constitutional framework, in particular the First Amendment and US case law; but some points, such as public funding and new institutions, are exploratory and raise practical and constitutional questions that the authors acknowledge and leave open, not just for the US context.

Tags: legal protection Safety of journalists Media freedom

The content of this article can be used according to the terms of Creative Commons: Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) . To do so use the the wording "this article was originally published on the Resource Centre on Media Freedom in Europe" including a direct active link to the original article page.